• Skip to main content

Aline Soules

Poet and Fiction Writer

  • Home
  • About
  • Books
    • Evening Sun
    • Meditation on Woman
    • The Size of the World
  • Contact

critique

Nov 19 2018

Kauai Writers Conference: Master Classes

I just came back from the Kauai Writers Conference re-energized and ready to write.  I’ve spent the week reviewing my notes and critiques, and have a lot of work to do.

One highlight was Master Classes.  I took one with Jeff Arch, the script writer for Sleepless in Seattle, among other stories.  He has a wealth of information to share and conveyed it in a free-wheeling series of anecdotes.  I came away with a renewed sense of story and the importance of eliminating anything extraneous.  We also spent time on “log lines,” which are very difficult to hone down to their essence.

The other class, with Jeff Kleinman, engaged all participants in discussion and critique. He divided our submissions (query letter, synopsis, first 10 p. of our books) into four days, each of which was devoted to a different category:  premise, character, voice, and momentum.  He has an unerring eye and his master class, devoted to making work publishable, was amazing.  He demonstrated how he reviews initial queries. He gets approx. 7,200/year and can sell maybe 4-5-6 books in that same year.  There’s no room for the smallest of errors or anything less than captivating, a salutary lesson.  

Of importance is the ability to listen to critique with an unemotional ear in order to gain the most from what we were given. Both class leaders were very generous with their time and expertise, but none of us had a novel that was “ready” for submission.  As part of the process, we were encouraged to persist, one of the most important attributes for a writer.  So, here we are: back home and writing.  

 

Next post will cover the main conference, which ran from Friday through Sunday.  

Image credit:  https://www.aiga.org/how-to-give-receive-design-critique, captured 18 Nov. 2018.

Written by Aline Soules · Categorized: Writing · Tagged: critique, kauai writers conference, novel elements

Dec 11 2017

Inspiration from my Scholar OLLI students

For the last couple of years, I’ve had the privilege of leading a class called “Writing in All Forms” for Scholar OLLI on the Concord Campus of California State University, East Bay.  

For those who don’t know, OLLI stands for Osher Lifelong Learning Institute.  The founder, Bernard Osher, makes grants from his foundation to provide noncredit courses to adults over 50.  There are OLLIs all over the U.S. and if anyone can claim a legacy, it’s Bernard Osher.  He promotes endless learning, not just for attendees, but for class leaders, too.

My class is filled with fabulous writers and I’m not the teacher, I’m the leader/guide. I learn as much as the people who attend.  Each session lasts only five weeks (there are three each academic year) and they whip by at a rate faster than Mach 1 because we have so much fun critiquing our writing and talking about our craft.  The class includes novelists and memoirists and poets and short story writers.  Attendees write every type of work from gut-wrenching to humor.  They’re fabulous.  And the stories they have to tell—in whatever form they choose—are amazing.  I learn about their unique lives and marvel at their gifts.

I’m deeply grateful at being offered the opportunity to be a part of this wonderful program.  It’s improved my own writing, given me a community of writers, and blessed me than I could have imagined.
 
 

Written by Aline Soules · Categorized: Writing · Tagged: Bernard Osher Foundation, California State University East Bay, critique, Osher Lifelong Learning Institute, teaching writing

Mar 10 2015

The Gift of Feedback

feedback-headsRecently, I’ve been fortunate to receive feedback on a number of pieces of my work.  This is such a gift.  You can write and write and write, but, eventually, you need other eyes to see what you can’t see because you’re too close to what you’ve written.  It all makes sense to you; then, someone comes along and is puzzled.

There are different types of feedback, but it’s all good.  You can make the most of it by accepting it.  This doesn’t mean you have to implement everything that’s suggested, but it does mean you need to set your ego aside and not take it personally.  People who are generous enough to give you feedback are your best writing friends.  Their honest feedback enables you to revise in ways you couldn’t have without their input. Feedback can range from the general to the structural to the syntax to the grammar.  Take it.  Figure out what resonates with your goals for the piece and make the most of it.

Photo credit:  Biodick

Written by Aline Soules · Categorized: Writing · Tagged: critique, feedback, revision, writing

Copyright © 2026 ·